Home > mindscape landmark, Philippine Advertising, Philippine Marketing, Uncategorized > BIR’s public shaming of doctors print ad – brilliant print ad, disparaging to doctors & it can be banned from publication

BIR’s public shaming of doctors print ad – brilliant print ad, disparaging to doctors & it can be banned from publication

Part 1 : BIR’s public shaming of doctors print ad is brilliant, it should win an ad congress award for excellence

20140304-090954.jpg

the BIR just launched what i call the “public shaming of doctors” (PSoD) ad campaign, above is the first print ad of the campaign. this doctor ad apparently is the first of three ad executions, with the accountants and online sellers being the next to be featured in two more ads. last night, i saw on GMA7 the TV version of the PSoD using accountants. we are assuming there are  2 more TV ad versions to come with doctors and online sellers.

the print ad has these elements :

> it features a doctor literally sitting on the shoulders of a teacher in a classroom setting

> the concept revolves the idea of tax cheats are a burden to honest taxpayers, in this ad represented literally as being put on the shoulders of the teacher. we all know that teachers in the philippines are not paid very well and yet their jobs are very important, very difficult and impacts the nation specially the youth in very significant ways. doctors on the hand we know to be high income individuals. we know that first hand through the professional fees we pay them in every visit to their clinics and when we need to pay hospital bills.

– the ad even includes a computation of the salaries and taxes paid by doctors and teachers where we see in very glaring numbers, shocking even that the doctor who earns much higher pays much lower taxes than the teacher.

– the ad ends with the tagline : “When you don’t pay your taxes, you’re a burden to those who do.”

from an advertising point of view we think this print ad is brilliant! we think it should win an award in the next ad congress.

> the ad’s message is very provocative. provocative is one of  the top 3 qualities that you want in an ad to be. it is in the top 3 by which you measure the effectiveness of  an ad. the responses and reactions it has been getting in social media and traditional media, both from doctors and citizens have been massive, for or against the ad, a good indicator of provocativeness (sic) for this kinds of ads.

>the ad concept and the visuals communicate the message very well and with ease. just by looking at the visuals, you understand the message of the ad.

the only push  back we have and this it is a minor one on this ad is the execution of the ‘burden”. we thought the ad could have been more effective if it showed more ‘burden” being suffered by the teacher.

i am guessing the ad agency thought of it but they probably decided against it as they probably knew it will be a controversial ad and pusing the burden more in the visuals might make the ad too much to bear for the audience.

> the strategy of the ad was spot on – the impact of tax cheats on taxpayers is real and full of credible and strong insight. the ill effect of the actions of tax cheats is not just on the government but also on individual citizens. being the weak link makes everyone else in the link weaker and burdened.

> the choice of the doctor and teacher for this comparison was brilliant and very effective, quickly understandable to the audience. almost by rote, we know that doctors are one of the highest paid in the country and teachers are one of the lowest paid.

we know of the doctors as we have our own experiences to base it on. for a visit to the doctor, we pay anywhere from P400 to P1,200 every consultation depending on the specialization and reputation of the doctor. those consultation fees are nothing when we or members of our family are hospitalized or God forbid goes through surgery. surgery fees of doctors range from P5T to P200T depending on what the surgery is.

our own experience also tells us the doctors we see almost always do not voluntarily issue official receipts after a consultation. they issue one only when we ask.

we know of teachers as we have read about them – on how their pay is so low and yet they do a lot of hard work, their roles important and even critical to nation building and to our children.

the doctor versus the teacher simply put gives an excellent and concrete contrast for the purpose of communicating disparities and burden.

>> more to come <<

~~~ mindscape landmark ~~~
carlo arvisu

Advertisements
  1. No comments yet.
  1. No trackbacks yet.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: